A Study of Suicide Mortality in Turkey ( 2002-2011 )

Suicide, a leading cause of premature death, has negative effects on both the relatives of people who commit suicide, and on society. The World Health Organization (WHO) defines suicide as the act of deliberately killing oneself. Experts agree that a combination of many factors plays a role in the emergence of suicidal behavior. Factors such as depression, psychiatric and neurological disorders, schizophrenia, addiction, cancer, as well as physical diseases and HIV infection can be given as reasons for suicide. Besides, suicide is correlated with hopelessness, psychological disorders, social isolation, biological predisposition, previous suicide attempts, mood disorders, domestic violence, work-related stress, financial difficulties and drugs (Sharma et al., 2007). It is well-known that there is a relationship between suicidal thoughts and the behavior of teenagers or young adults, who are exposed to sexual or physical abuse in their childhoods, having a divorced family, Abstract


Introduction
Suicide, a leading cause of premature death, has negative effects on both the relatives of people who commit suicide, and on society.The World Health Organization (WHO) defines suicide as the act of deliberately killing oneself.Experts agree that a combination of many factors plays a role in the emergence of suicidal behavior.Factors such as depression, psychiatric and neurological disorders, schizophrenia, addiction, cancer, as well as physical diseases and HIV infection can be given as reasons for suicide.Besides, suicide is correlated with hopelessness, psychological disorders, social isolation, biological predisposition, previous suicide attempts, mood disorders, domestic violence, work-related stress, financial difficulties and drugs (Sharma et al., 2007).It is well-known that there is a relationship between suicidal thoughts and the behavior of teenagers or young adults, who are exposed to sexual or physical abuse in their childhoods, having a divorced family, being separated from parents, or living with people involved in crime (Sharma et al., 2007).Also, it is observed that some people commit suicide for religious purposes on political objectives and wars.(Bosnar vd., 2006;Smith and Frueh, 2013).It is well-known that socio-economic factors play an important role in the distribution of suicide.Durkheim states that the risk of suicide is related to social factors, such as low income, unemployment and educational failure (Agerbo et al., 2011;Bedeian, 1982;Kuroki, 2010).
The results of suicide impact, not only on those who commit suicide, but also on families and society.According to the WHO, the annual global mortality rate of suicide is about 16 per 100,000 people for the year 2000, with one person committing suicide every 40 seconds.Suicide is one of the three major causes of death in the 15-44 age range.According to official data taken from the Turkish Statistical Institute for 2008, deaths due to suicide are the ninth order of 50 causes of death.In the same year, 215,562 people lost their lives due to 50 different reasons.Of these, 0.74% of men and 0.46% of women committed suicide.
Suicide, a preventable public health problem, is listed as an external cause of death.Research on suicide is important because it is a preventable cause of death.Studies help to show which factors can be changed and what kind of intervention can be conducted for certain age groups in order to prevent suicide.Much research has considered mental illness and substance abuse as primary risk factors, and thus most suicide prevention programs emphasize these causes in order to lower the risk of suicide.As a result, suicide prevention strategies generally involve reaching out to preventable factors which would decrease risk factors that stem from mental health problems (NIMH).In a world where discussions based on policies and programs which would address suicidal behavior and where attempts to develop new methods to reach out to higher risk groups and suicide prevention, prevention strategies can only be developed through better research and an understanding of suicide geography.This is because suicide changes through different regions and cultures.The weight of risk factors associated with suicide differs for each country, due to each country's unique circumstances.Differences in mortality rates stem not only from cultural and religious attitudes, the status of women and family structures in a given society, but can also vary spatially within a country (Cutright and Fernquist, 2000).To develop a national suicide prevention strategy, a thorough understanding of all aspects of suicide, a determination of country-specific risk factors, high risk sub-groups and a clear definition of their geographical distribution are needed.
Suicide is a complex phenomenon in all regions of the world because it varies greatly depending on the time, place, age group, gender, race, culture, religion, social systems and region.In the literature, suicide mortality has been studied from different angles.While some studies focus on the reasons for suicide or ways to prevent suicide, some consider the spatial distribution of suicide mortality (Hintikka et al. 1999 According to research, human biology is substantially affected by the environment (Hjelmeland, 2011).Therefore, the environment or geography plays an important role in a person's motivation to commit suicide (Mann et al., 2009).For these reasons, in order to determine the effect of geographical conditions on suicide rates, many studies have been conducted.According to these studies, climatic conditions, such as sunny or foggy days have affected suicidal behavior, and moreover, depending on these conditions, the methods of suicide can change.On the other hand, some researchers suggest that geographical conditions may be directly related to an increase in suicide rates (Hempstead, 2006;Rehkopf and Buka, 2006).
In studies on the geographical distribution of suicide, it has been identified that suicide prevalence shows geographical variation (Gunnell et al., 1995;Micciolo et al., 1991;Middleton et al., 2008;Levin and Leyland, 2005;Middleton et al., 2006).For example, the national suicide rates in European counties are considerably different (Levi et al., 2003).Moreover, the prevalence and incidence of the suicide rate in a specified country can be different regionally.In other words, it has emerged that these differences may be due to significant geographical features.The uneven distribution of suicide rates between countries and among the regions of a particular country has led to the emergence of the hypothesis that suicide is associated with location (Rehkopf and Buka, 2006;Ngui et al. 2014).For this reason, understanding the spatial distribution of suicide mortality can provide assistance for the planning of suicide prevention actions.
The announced numbers concerning suicide mortality are generally obtained from official statistics.As in many countries, the act of suicide is considered to be a derogatory action in terms of social and religious views in Turkey (Aktepe et. al., 2005).Therefore, the actual size of the mortality rate due to suicide may be greater than the announced figures for Turkey.It should not be overlooked that a number of deaths are accepted as accidents or natural deaths.
The objective of this study is to evaluate the spatial clustering of suicide of males and females in Turkey between 2002 and 2011 by means of both statistical analyses and mapping analysis.It should be highlighted that this study on the spatial analysis of the suicide mortality rate in Turkey for the period 2002-2011 is being conducted for the first time.
Considering all these issues, the paper is organized as follows.The data used and spatial analysis are described in Section 2. Discussion on the obtained findings is also provided in Section 3. Finally, the last section summarizes the conclusions of the study.

Data and Spatial Analysis
Turkey is divided into seven regions: Marmara, Aegean, Black Sea, Central Anatolia, Eastern Anatolia, South East Anatolia and the Mediterranean Region, and also divided into 81 provinces administratively.It is clear that narrow geographical area units are more suitable than the provincial level in order to characterize the socio-economic environment (Middleton, et. al. 2008).However, suicide mortality data can only be reached at only the provincial level in Turkey.Thus, this study is limited due to the provincial level.The suicide mortality rate data are taken from the Turkish Statistical Institute.
Using the adjusted total number of suicide cases is more useful in determining a seasonal distribution of deaths.In this study, the monthly adjusted total number of suicide cases is used for deaths resulting from suicide.The adjusted total of suicide cases is calculated by standardizing a 30day distribution of cases for each month (Sun et al., 2011).
Firstly, the spatial pattern of suicides in Turkey is analyzed via suicide maps.Standardized data were used in these suicide mortality rate maps.Since the mortality variable depends on population structure and size, spatial pattern and time, the misleading nature of demographic variables, such as population size and age groups should be eliminated in order to compare different communities in terms of death rate (Günay, 2010;Anderson and Rosenberg, 1998).In this study, we have calculated the rate of suicides per 100,000 of the population.By using a direct age adjusted method and the results of the Turkey 2000 Census, suicide data are standardized.In this study, we use average province-level suicide rate data by sex covering the 2002-2011 period.In this study, a district level map of Turkey is used and maps were prepared using MapInfo.For mortality rate maps, a double-ended scheme is generally accepted as a better representation of rates above and below the mean (Pickle et al., 1996:8) where n is the total number of spatial observations (i.e.districts), xi is the value measured in region i, xj is the value for another region j .x is the mean value of all regions and wij is the spatial weight between regions i and j.
As seen from formula I, in order to calculate Moran's I for spatial autocorrelation, the spatial weights matrix should be calculated.There are three kinds of weight matrices; contiguity, based on distance, and k-nearest neighbor.In this study, a spatial weights matrix based on 4nearest neighbors is used.
The Moran scatter plot of the male suicide mortality rate is demonstrated in Fig. 6.It can be seen that the X-axis shows male suicide mortality rates and the Y-axis shows lagged-male suicide mortality rates defined by the weights matrix.Global Moran's I statistic only provides an overall measure whether data are clustered or not.Specifically, it does not indicate local clusters or local levels of spatial autocorrelation.In order to identify local clustering geographically, Luc Anselin's LISA (Local Indicators of Spatial Association) is used as a local statistic (Anselin, 1995).This local statistic provides LISA map to quantify spatial autocorrelation and clustering within the small areas.(See Kantar and Aktas, 2016) Also, it can be seen from Figure 1 that suicide mortality rates in Turkey are higher among men than among women, as it is worldwide.Compared to suicide among men, factors such as strong family ties, children and sense of responsibility can protect women against suicide.It is known that one of the five main reasons for suicide is illness for both males and females (Günay, 2014).

Suicide Rates by Age Group
Age group distribution is important in determining the scope and commonly observed risk groups of suicide.According to 10 year averages in Turkey, suicide among males is mostly observed in the 15-24 and 25-34 ( The age group distribution for male suicide in Turkey is similar to those of the Americas and the world average.The 15-29 age group has the highest male suicide rate in Turkey, as well as in the Americas, Southeast Asia, Africa and Eastern Mediterranean.In these regions, the suicide rates decrease after the age of 30. However, this rate continues at the same level in Turkey.Even though suicide rates decrease for the 30-59 age group throughout the world and the Americas, the rates are still high, which is also the case for Turkey.The lowest suicide rate in Turkey is observed among young males at a rate of 1.4% (Figure 2).

Figure 3: Global distribution of male suicide rates for different age groups
The age group distribution for female suicide in Turkey is similar to those of Southeast Asia and the eastern Mediterranean regions.Female suicide rates for the 15-34 age group are higher than other age groups.This indicates the severity of suicide for young women.In recent years, a variation in suicide mortality rates within different age groups has been observed in industrialized countries.Negative trends are mostly observed among young people (Middleton et al., 2008) Turkey differs from the world regarding suicide among the elderly.In Turkey, for both males and females, the number of suicide cases decreases, whereas this number remains high for those who are above 60 worldwide.Similarly, suicide cases for elderly males are much higher throughout the world, but in Turkey, there is not much difference across genders for elderly people.The number of female suicide cases is lowest for those above 75 and above.This situation also differs from the world average.Increasing health problems, loss of ability due to chronic diseases such as heart problems and cancer, incurable depression and isolation from the social environment increase the risk of suicide.On the other hand, it is possible that, due to physical disabilities and a higher probability of accidents occurring due to aging, these suicide cases might not have been determined or recorded.
The suicide rate for females below the age of 15 is 5.3%.This rate shows the problem of pre-adolescent suicide in Turkey, as the world average for females in this age group is much lower (Worldwide 2.1%; eastern Mediterranean 3.7%).This figure is much lower for males for the same age group in Turkey.This situation suggests that further attention should be paid to pre-adolescent female suicides in Turkey.Studies show that the number of pre-adolescent or teen suicide attempts in Turkey is higher (Akın and Berkem, 2012).Preventive measures need to be taken for pre-adolescent suicide attempts and suicides.As a result, this area requires further investigation.

Causes of Suicide
Among the 6283 suicide cases in Turkey, between 2002 and 2011, the cause of suicide is unknown for most (37%).For suicide cases where the causes are known, 23% took place because of diseases.Family (14%) and economic problems (10%) are among other causes (See Figure 4).

Seasonality of Suicide
Even though weather conditions are not a major cause of suicide, studies show that in both hemispheres suicide cases reach a maximum during spring and the initial phases of summer, and reach a minimum during winter.(Kevan, 1980;Jessen et al., 1999;Oravecz et al., 2006;Masterton, 199).For females, the second most commonly observed season for high suicide rates is autumn.Studies did not show any relationship between suicide and seasonality in the equatorial region (Parker et al., 2001).In European countries, a significant distribution of seasonality of suicide cases has decreased towards the end of the 20th century (Ajdacic-Gross, 2005), whereas in Australia, the seasonality of these cases has increased (Rock et al., 2003).Seasonal pattern of suicide differs in accordance with certain population subgroups.A number of studies show no difference by gender in terms of seasonality of suicide mortality (Oravecz et al., 2006;Lee et al., 2006).Masterton (1991) suggests that the seasonality effect on female suicide is higher (1991).On the other hand, other studies indicate that seasonal effects are much higher for males than for females (Oravecz et al 2006;Rock et al., 2003).
The distribution of total suicide rates by gender and month in Turkey, which is a northern hemisphere country with a subtropical climate, for the period 2002-2011, is shown at Figure 5. Suicide rates are adjusted by a 30 day distribution.Males in Turkey mostly commit suicide in the summer and spring months.The lowest suicide rate is observed in November (6.3%).This rate increases until June (%10) and then starting from July, it decreases (9.7%).Male suicide is mostly observed between the months of February and October.The lowest period is between the months of November and January.
Females mostly commit suicide in the summer and spring months.The monthly distribution of the female suicide rate falls one month behind male suicide rates.The lowest female suicide rate is observed in December (6.4%).After December, this rate increases and reaches a maximum in July (10%) and, starting from August, it starts to decrease (9.7%).Since no significant period of increase is observed for female suicide, the most commonly observed period for female suicide starts in March and extends to October.The lowest female suicide rates are observed in winter, between December and February.
There is no second period of increase in for female suicide (Günay, 2014).

Spatial Pattern of Suicide
Suicide prevention strategies can be correctly diagnosed with a better analysis of spatial differences, processes and interactions.As a result of this, a spatial pattern of suicide by gender is presented with a city-level distribution.Firstly, we research whether there is spatial clustering of suicide mortality rates for males and females in Turkey between 2002 and 2011.There are various factors that influence suicidal behavior.Slight alternation in any one of these factors can trigger consequences.Generational conflict and gender conflict are considered to be the explanatory reasons in the high suicide rates in countries which return rapidly from traditional agricultural society to industrial society (Sharma et. al, 2007;Chuang and Huang, 1996).On the other hand, migration is one of the most important socio-environmental factors associated with suicide (Voracek, et. al., 2009).It is well-known that Turkey has been experiencing rapid urbanization and a rapid migration process since 1950.
Accordingly, the share of the population living in cities is increasing.While 25% of the population lived in cities in 1950, this rate reached 75% in 2012.While the number of cities exceeding one million population was sixteen 2012, this number was only one in 1950 (Bekdemir, et. al., 2015).In Turkey, the proportion of people living in the cities and the number of cities and metropolitan have increased.These are features of Turkey's urbanization (Doğanay 1997: 427).This urbanization of Turkey has not developed in parallel with the industrialization.Therefore, certain problems like squatters, the accumulation of the rural population, unemployment, environmental pollution, social, economic, political and planning have been experienced.86% of those who commit suicide throughout the world is composed of citizens in low and middle-income countries (WHO).Turkey, which is a developing country and thus has rapid migration movement, and has a rapidly changing socio-cultural and socio economic structure, has suicide rates less than countries on the European continent (Günay 2014: 10-22).The effect of religious structures on suicide should not be overlooked.While suicide is considered as an honorable choice in some religions and cultures, this action is definitely an unforgiven act in Islam.
A similar design is formed for female suicide as shown in Figure 8.It can be seen from Figure 8 that Moran's I is 0.274829 for the male suicide mortality rate, which indicates that there is a moderate level spatial clustering in male suicide mortality in Turkey.Also, the p-value of Moran's I is less than 0.05 and thus, Moran's I is statistically meaningful.On the other hand, for the female suicide mortality rate, Moran's I value is approximately 0.20025 (See Figure 9).This means that there is a global spatial correlation.According to Fig. 10, provinces in the southern west part of Turkey such as Mugla, Aydin, Denizli and Burdur replaced in High-High (HH).It means that indicates higher values surrounded by neighboring units with higher values, and that there is positive spatial autocorrelation and neighborhood effect.According to Fig. 11, the H-H cluster with the high female suicide rate is still located in the Ardahan and Agri.

Conclusions
Research on suicide is important since suicide is a preventable cause of death.Such studies help to show which factors can be changed and what kind of intervention can be conducted for certain age groups in order to prevent suicide.Differences in suicide mortality rates arise not only from cultural and religious attitudes, the status of women and family structures in a given society, but can also vary spatially within a country.To develop a national suicide prevention strategy, a thorough understanding of all aspects of suicide, a determination of country-specific risk factors, high risk sub-groups and a clear definition of their geographical distribution are needed.In Turkey, suicide mortality rates are higher among men than among women, as it is worldwide.Compared to suicide among men, factors such as strong family ties, children and sense of responsibility can protect women against suicide.It is known that one of the five main reasons for suicide is illness for both males and females.If the age groups are taken into account, the 15-29 age group has the highest male suicide rate in Turkey as in the Americas, Southeast Asia, Africa, Eastern Mediterranean.The lowest suicide rate in Turkey is observed among young males at a rate of 1.4%.Female suicide rates for the 15-34 are higher than the other age groups.This indicates the severity of suicide for young women.Turkey differs from the world regarding suicide among the elderly.In Turkey, for both males and females, the number of suicide cases decreases, whereas this number remains high for those who are above 60 worldwide.Similarly, suicide cases for elderly males are much higher throughout the world, but in Turkey, there is not much difference across genders for elderly people.When the causes of suicide are taken into account by gender, unknown causes and diseases for males and females have the highest rates.Family problems, educational problems, emotional problems and unwanted marriages are higher for females than males as causes of suicide.Economic problems and business failures are higher for males than females as causes of suicide.If suicide in Turkey is analyzed seasonally and spatially, it is found that males in Turkey mostly commit suicide in the summer and spring months.

Figure 1 Figure 1 :
Figure1shows the changes in the suicide mortality in Turkey over time.It can be seen that while the male suicide has increased up to2009  and decreased between 2009 and 2011, the total rate suicide has been generally stable for the period 2002-2010.The female suicide rate has tended to decrease after 2003.In 2002, 2301 people committed suicide in Turkey.This number sharply increased to 2705 in 2003 and up to 2006 the number of suicide cases remained roughly at this level.In 2006, this number increased to 2829 suicides and then decreased to 2793 in 2007.Starting from 2008, the trend started to increase, and in 2010 this number reached 2933, its highest level.In 2011, 2677 people committed suicide.

Figure 5 :
Figure 5: Suicide rate by month (December to November) according to gender in Turkey (2002-2011) (Blue line for male and red line for female)

Figure 8 :
Figure 8: Moran's I for male suicide rates

Figure 9 :Figure 10 :Figure 11 :
Figure 9: Moran's I for female suicide rates in double ended colored grid maps for the years between 2002 and 2011, for suicide average maps.In these maps, the highest and lowest values for deaths are represented in red and blue, respectively.Values in between the highest and lowest values are calculated using the interpolation method.To do this, Inverse Distance Weighted algorithm is used.These maps are effective where variations in disease and mortality rates cannot be represented by definite (or drawn) borders, and where clustering of closer values need to be presented.

Suicide Rate Figure 2: Distribution of suicide mortality in Turkey by age groups and gender (2002- 2011) Grey line for Total, Blue line for Male, Red line for Female ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
14.2% and 14.3%) age groups.The male suicide rate decreases by 2% for the age groups 35-44 and 45-54.After the age of 55 this rate decreases.

924023 Figure 6: Spatial distribution of the age-adjusted male suicide mortality rates for 2002-2011
______________ Semra Günay Aktaşand Yeliz Mert Kantar (2016), Journal of EU Research in Business, DOI: 10.5171/2016.______________Semra Günay Aktaşand Yeliz Mert Kantar (2016), Journal of EU Research in Business, DOI: 10.5171/2016.924023 The lowest suicide rate is observed in November.Male suicide is mostly observed between the months of February and October.The lowest period is between the months of November and January.It is found that the suicide rates for males and females are high for East Anatolia, South East Anatolia, the South West Aegean region and some coastal provinces of the west and central Black Sea sub-regions.The obtained Moran's I values for male and female suicide mortality rates indicate that there is a moderate level of spatial clustering of male and female suicide mortality in Turkey.Normalization for the disparity indicative variables according to age on the health geography: Direct age adjustment example,' VI.Ulusal Coğrafya