Integration of Quality Management System in the Malaysian Construction Industry

Quality management system (QMS) is defined as the managing structure, responsibilities, procedures, processes, and management resources to implement the principles and action lines needed to achieve the quality objectives of an organization. QMS is conventionally being associated with the manufacturing industry as it is used to direct and control an organization with regard to the end-product quality via various QMS manufacturing models, namely Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, the ISO 9000 quality standards, Total Quality Management (TQM), Six Sigma and Lean. However, since the construction industry appears to be going through a period of introspection, with the increasing of technological innovation in design concepts, use of new and unique materials, novel methods of construction, complex social issues, rapid environmental change as well as obnoxious problems of delay, over-budget and low quality, QMS is observed by this paper as the solution to this dilemma. Hence, this paper aims at appraising the integration of QMS in the Malaysian construction industry. It is expected that the findings of this paper would help the project management team of the construction projects to efficiently manage the construction activities throughout the whole project life cycle from pre-contract to post-contract phase via the integration of QMS.


Introduction
With the turn of this new millennium, the construction industry appears going through a period of introspection, with the increasing of technological innovation in design concepts, use of new and unique materials as well as novel methods of construction, complex social issues and rapid environmental change.These changes affect the way business is conducted; where quality expectation of clients and end-users has grown relentlessly due to an increasing demand for better living standard and value for money (Al-Momani, 2000; Economic Planning Unit, 2010).According to Nelson and Holt (1999), no organization operating in the construction industry, whether large or small, private or public, can afford to ignore its changing environment if it is to survive.
In Malaysia, residential development in low, medium and high cost demonstrates very strong demands, needs and supply due to population increase, which is expected to be about 32 millions in year 2020 (Economic Planning Unit, 2010).Hence, it is a major challenge in the areas of efficiency and effectiveness of the Quality Management System (QMS) in the construction industry in order to sustain in this complex environment.Therefore, management of construction companies is required to have sufficient understanding and ability in addressing complexity in planning, coordination, and control requirements (Austin et al, 2002;Jack and Samuel, 2006) in order to work well, work fast, work smart, and produce results for the projects.However, a lot of projects performance dissatisfaction can be found among both private and public projects.To deal with project performance efficiently and effectively for the balance on the better value for clients and reasonable profits for the construction companies to ensure their longterm future, integrating of quality management system (QMS) is essential to ensure sustainability in the construction industry.Therefore, this paper aims at appraising the integration of QMS in the Malaysian construction industry.
The general review on the QMS is undertaken, followed with the in-depth discussion on the ISO 9000-Based Quality Management Systems, which is the main mechanism of the QMS integration in the Malaysian construction industry.

Reviews of Quality Management System (QMS)
There are many definitions of the Quality Management System (QMS).QMS can be defined as "the managing structure, responsibilities, procedures, processes and management resources to implement the principles and action lines needed to achieve the quality objectives of an organisation".In addition, QMS is also defined by The International Organization for Standardization (ISO) as "the management system used to direct and control an organization with regard to quality".The models such as Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, the ISO 9000 quality standards, Total Quality Management (TQM), Six Sigma and Lean are amongst the acknowledged QMS models worldwide and being used successfully across different industries, particularly the manufacturing industry.
Nevertheless, it is important to note that successful implementation of QMS in manufacturing are being adopted and integrated into construction industry for more than two decades, especially the ISO 9000 series of Quality Systems Standards.The concept of QMS as an initiative is to solve quality problems and to meet the needs of end-users (Kanji and Wong, 1998).There are many reasons and benefits that have been suggested as to why companies seek quality certification (Yeoh et al., 1996).The effects of QMS implementation have also been studied by McIntyre and Kirschenman (2000), where it is found that more repeat customers and reduced rework are amongst the most obvious benefits demonstrated via the implementation of QMS.Torbica and Stroh (1999) as "For the first time an empirical study has confirmed that implementation of TQM is positively associated with home-buyer satisfaction".Love et al. (1999) who concluded a study on the effects of rework in construction project also claim that the increased cost and time are found to be as high as 12 percents and 11 percents respectively.
On the other hand, the survey conducted by Shaw (1995) on 35 selected contractors in investigating the original motivations in seeking a QMS certification also shows the positive effects of QMS implementation.The summary of the survey results is indicated in Table 1.From the results, five out of seven items, which are from item 3 to 7, provide the least motivations to the organizations.It is found by Shaw (1995) that the constructors failed to gain benefits due to wrong thinking on implementing the QMS, which is due to mainly the pressure of the government or clients in seeking qualified certification and the solution for the problems in cost, quality, risk and the like.Therefore, the overall benefits gained as a result of implementing the QMS have not been significant.(Tsim et al., 2002), which provides comprehensive guidance on the scope, implementation and the principles based on eight principles of Total Quality Management (TQM) (Beattie, 1999; Jay and Barry, 2014) from Dr. Deming's Fourteen Points.These include customer focus, leadership, involvement of people, process approach, system approach to management, continual improvement, factual approach to decision making and mutually beneficial supplier relationship as shown in Table 2 (David et al., 2013).Establish unity of purpose and organizational direction and provide an environment that promotes employee involvement and achievement of objectives.
3 Involvement of people Take advantages of fully involved employees, using all their abilities for the benefit of the organization.

Process Approach
Recognize that things accomplished are the results of processes along with related activities and resources that must be managed.

System Approach to Management
The multiple interrelated processes that contribute to the organization's effectiveness are a system and should be managed as a system.

Continual Improvement
Continual improvement should be a permanent objective applied to the organization and to its people, processes, systems, ands products.

Factual Approach to Decision Making
Decisions must be based on the analysis of accurate, relevant, and reliable data and information.Hence, the ISO 9000 has caused construction companies to focus only on improving the implementation of ISO9000 certified by accreditation bodies, as they can achieve their performance in accordance with the international standards with guidance from the International Accreditation Forum (IAF).Their performances are generally measured or assessed based on their operation within financial constraints, successfully gaining market position and obtaining profitability.Evidence from Hong Kong shows that this is especially true for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in the service and construction sectors (Lee, 1998).Furthermore, Sonny Nwankwo (2000) finds that image is one of the factors that motivate a company to adopt ISO 9000 certification.
According to Tang et al. (2005) , 1995) agrees that the effective quality management system that meets the ISO 9000 standard can lead to cost and time savings and better quality projects.However, although more construction companies are being certified with ISO certification, they always have wrong perception that would have competitive edge in bidding contract and a low tender price is still the main factor in winning contracts.In addition, countries such as the United Kingdom (UK), Hong Kong and Singapore reveal that the ISO 9000 implementation is very encouraging at the initial stage but over the time, it becomes burdensome to all parties involved if the right approaches not adopted (Giles, 1997;Kam and Tang, 1997;Abdul and Mat, 2006).For instance, the companies are always trapped in the ISO 9000 registration on the excessive overhead and paperwork; and there will be the risk of poor company image if the certificate process or maintenance failed.Therefore, ISO 9000 is seen lay down what QMS must do but not how QMS should do.

Conclusion
Construction industry is a very complicated industry.To meet the objectives of the construction management, strategic management techniques are vital.However, specific quality management knowledge areas are required in managing the construction activities throughout the whole project life cycle from pre-contract to postcontract phase.Hence, the integration of the Quality Management System (QMS) into the practices of construction industry is observed by this paper as essential to achieve better management of the construction activities.Among the benefits of integrating the QMS: improving the company's quality image in the construction industry, improving the company's efficiency and management, resolving the problems with poor quality arising construction processes, reducing the failure costs and liability risks, fulfilling the mandate from the Government, satisfying the demands from the private owners/clients and becoming a stepping stone for implementing Total Quality Management (TQM).
It is also important to adopt the eight principles of Total Quality Management (TQM) from Dr. Deming's Fourteen Points, which include customer focus, leadership, involvement of people, process approach, system approach to management, continual improvement, factual approach to decision making and mutually beneficial supplier relationship.Proper implementation of QMS is expected to efficiently manage the construction activities throughout the 360 degree of project life cycle.
Effects of customer satisfaction are being concluded by The Journal of Organizational Management Studies __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ______________ Poh Ngoh Kiew, Syuhaida Ismail and Aminah Mohd Yusuf (2016), The Journal of Organizational Management Studies, DOI: 10.5171/2016.117211

Table 1 : Original motivations survey results on seeking a QMS
(Nesan and Holt, 1999a lack of appreciation of QMS approach in managing construction projects due to non-standardisation, where projects look similar but not identical with non-repetition.In support of this, many authors point out that non-standardisation is one of the main barriers of implementation of quality tools in construction(Nesan and Holt, 1999; Karim et al., 2005; Peter et al., 2010).______________ Poh Ngoh Kiew, Syuhaida Ismail and Aminah Mohd Yusuf (2016), The Journal of Organizational Management Studies, DOI: 10.5171/2016.117211

Table 4 : Worldwide Total of ISO 9001-Quality Management System-Requirement Certificates
Syuhaida Ismail and Aminah Mohd Yusuf (2016), The Journal of Organizational Management Studies, DOI: 10.5171/2016.117211certified with ISO certification if they wish to bid for public projects.Despite that, a view from Master Builders Association of Malaysia (MBAM