Burnout – a Romanian overview

In this paper, our goal is to analyze the burnout level among Romanian employees, using Maslach Burnout Inventory. In our opinion, this study is important mainly due to the fact that in Romania burnout tends to become a very frequent phenomenon, especially among young employees. Another reason why we consider the study important is due to the fact that, from the research undertaken by us, there are only a couple of studies of this type in Romania. The article will attempt to establish the level of burnout by analyzing its three components, namely Emotional Exhaustion, Depersonalization and Personal Accomplishment. Although there are currently many authors who base their studies only on the first two components (Emotional Exhaustion and Depersonalization), they, and especially the first, being recognized as defining burnout syndrome, this study focused on analyzing all three components.


_____________________________________________________________________________
(that can leads to lack of the ability of the employees to fulfill the requirements of the job), control (burnout is generally showing up when employees feel they have no possibility to influence the work-related decisions), rewards (when they are insufficient and when there is no recognition), the community (referring to the lack of support on which relations between colleagues are characterized), fairness (equity and social justice) and values (when the personal values that initially attracted the employee to the current job begin to diverge from the organizational ones). The effects of burnout are considered to be job dissatisfaction, low organizational commitment, absenteeism, intention to leave the job, and turnover (Maslach, C. & Leiter, M. P., 2016, 105). Crawford, E.A. & Jeffery A. LePine, J.A. (2010,836) identified the relationship between the burnout and job demand, namely that a constant increase in an employee's efforts to meet the job demand gradually leads to her/him being drained of energy, both physical and mental, the employee feeling, over time, that it is used and worn out. Maslach, C., Jackson, S. E. & Leiter, M. P. (1996,194) considered burnout as a psychological state, which manifests itself through emotional exhaustion (employees feel drained of emotional resources, experiencing the feeling that they can no longer devote themselves to work), depersonalization (employees have negative attitudes, cynical dreams of work) and a feeling of low personal fulfillment (employees feel dissatisfied with their own person, as well as in relation to the results of their work). The tool developed by the authors for measuring burnout was Maslach Burnout Inventory, used to evaluate the three psychological states that characterize this syndrome. Maslach Burnout Inventory has 22 elements, divided into three subscales and presented in the form of statements regarding personal attitudes or feelings. The emotional exhaustion subscale contains nine elements and that of depersonalization five. Since the elements on these two subscales measure emotional exhaustion and, respectively, the lack of sensitivity and the depersonalized responses in relation to work, the results with high values on these two subscales prove a high level of burnout. It should also be noted that these two subscales are considered by the authors to present certain moderate correlations between them, which is consistent with the theoretical findings that the two components, although, separate, constitutes associated aspects of burnout. The subscale relating to personal fulfillment, consisting of eight elements, is considered to be independent, having only a reduced correlation with the other two. Unlike the first two scales, the results of small values on this scale are specific to a high level of burnout, because the components are used to measure feelings of competence and achievement. Halbesleben, J. R.B. & Demerouti, E. (2005, 209) even show that certain authors consecrate to be more suited to a model based only on Emotional Exhaustion and Depersonalization, especially because of less strong relationships that are established between Personal Accomplishment and organizational results, while Emotional Exhaustion and Depersonalization present strong relationships with them.

Research objectives
Even if burnout syndrome is a very common topic in the academic literature and in the studies conducted by practitioners, in Romania very little research has been undertaken on this topic (especially among medical staff). The primary objective of this paper was to identify the burnout level of the employees from Romanian companies. Maslach Burnout Inventory was used and its three components were analyzed: Emotional Exhaustion, Depersonalization and Personal Achievement. The second objective of the paper was to identify the burnout level of the employees from Romanian companies based on demographic characteristics.

Research hypotheses
The following hypotheses were the basis of the study that we undertook: -H1: the burnout level of employees from Romanian companies is high -H2: the number of female individuals experiencing a high burnout level is higher than the male number -H3: the highest percentage of people experiencing high burnout levels is registered among people with a high level of education -H4: the highest percentage of people experiencing high burnout levels is registered among people with a higher level of professional experience

Methodology
The research was carried out using a questionnaire developed in Google Forms and uploaded to Facebook within groups with specific themes in Romania (accounting and tax consulting, HR and labor legislation, legal, entrepreneurship). This method was adopted in view of the social distance requirements imposed by the COVID-19 pandemic. Although critical from the point of view of the possibility of building a representative sample of the employed population in Romania, we consider this way of distributing the questionnaire as compliant in terms of respecting the conditions for obtaining relevant results, namely respect for privacy (respondents are not influenced by other people's answers) and respect for confidentiality (respondents must be convinced that they can express their real feelings) (Maslach , C., Jackson, S.E., & Leiter, M. P. (1996, 195).
Maslach Burnout Inventory was used with 22 questions: nine questions for The Emotional Exhaustion scale, five questions for Depersonalization scales and eight questions for Personal Achievement scales. As a way of answering a Likert scale in 7 steps was used. We adopted the 7-step scale (based on intensity) because Worley, J.A., Vassar, M., Wheeler, D. L. & Barnes, L. L.B. (2008,(798)(799) found that most studies based their research on a 5-trap scale (frequency).

Population
The population of this study is composed of 160 people.
The respondents were both male and female and the gender frequency is shown in the table below. The population repartition by area of residence is shown in Table 2. The response for this article were given by respondents with different ages and a large variety of seniority level, as shown in Table 3 and Table 4.  It is important to be mentioned that both for age and seniority level the largest amount of data were collected for the most active categories on the labor market at this moment.
We considered the respondent's educational level as being important for the relevance of this studies. The categories of educational level and the repartition for each category are shown in Table 5. It should be mentioned that the survey included primary school and gymnasium as the last form of education completed, but no answer was received for these categories.  (2014,390) found that over time this idea was dropped out and the specialists conceptualized the burnout so that it could become applicable to all fields of activity.
The results obtained after processing the data collected are shown in the tables shown below:    The conclusion is that a large number of employees from the population of the research show a high level of Emotional Exhaustion (28,75%). Also, we consider as being very alarming the significant level of employees which resent a medium level of Emotional Exhaustion (62,50%). These employees can in any moment stat to experience a high level of Emotional Exhaustion if the organizations will not take urgent measures in order to reduce stress factor.
The category which experience the most Emotional Exhaustion is: female/master studies/age between 25-38 years/10-15 years of professional experience.

Depersonalization
Halbesleben, J. R. B., & Demerouti, E. (2005,208) showed that Depersonalization refers to a negative, callous, or excessively detached response to various aspects of the job, response that can be either exacerbated or excessively detached.
The results obtained after processing the data collected are shown in the tables shown below:    The study reveals a small amount of employees which presents a high level of Depersonalization (6,25%). Instead, the number of employees experiencing a medium level of Depersonalization is very large (71,88%). We consider that the reason for which a part of the employees experience a medium and not a high level of Depersonalization is due generally to personal factors (generally in Romanian organizations employees used to adopt more friendly and human relationships during working hours).
The category which experience the most Depersonalization is: female/college studies/age between 39-45 years/15-25 years of professional experience.

Personal Accomplishment
Maslach, C., Schaufeli, W.B. & Leiter, M. P. (2001,399) believes that Personal Accomplishment is manifested by feelings of lack of personal achievement, lack of competence and lack of productivity.    Our analysis shows that there is only a small number of employees which resent a high level of Personal Accomplishment (0,63%). The rest resent a low level (46,25%) or a medium level (53,13%) of Personal Accomplishment. The conclusion is that the largest number of employees resent a lack of achievement and a misfit with their current job.

Conclusions
The results of the study reveal the fact that the biggest number of employees resent a medium level of burnout (63,13%).

Limitations
The way of distributing the questionnaire in order to collect the answers did not allow us to carry out a sample that is representative of the entire population of Romania. Thus, one can notice the very small number of male employees who answered the questionnaire, which is why a comparison between female and male employees in terms of burnout level is limited. The answers were provided only by people with at least high school, which did not allow us to measure the burnout level of people with primary and secondary education. Also, being published in groups with a certain specificity, we consider that it was not possible to measure the burnout level for all categories of employees in Romania. Another limitation we consider to be the small number of respondents.